The Importance of Backtesting and Journaling Before Strategy Automation

Automation can free traders from constant screen time, but before handing your strategy over to an algorithm, there are two steps you can’t skip: backtesting and journaling. These practices give you the data, confidence, and discipline to know whether your strategy is truly ready to run on autopilot.

Step 1: Manual Backtesting on Historical Data

Manual backtesting means going through past price charts candle by candle and applying your rules as if you were trading live.

How to do it:

• Pick a chart and timeframe that fits your strategy.
• Scroll back in history so you can’t see what comes next.
• Move forward one candle at a time and check if your entry and exit rules are triggered.
• Record every trade — entry, stop-loss, take-profit, and result.

This process is slower than automated testing, but it gives you:

• A deeper understanding of how your strategy reacts to different market conditions.
• Insight into patterns, mistakes, or exceptions you wouldn’t notice otherwise.
• Confidence that your rules are realistic, not just theoretical.

Step 2: Compare with Live Market Tests

Historical results are only part of the picture. Markets change, spreads vary, and execution differs in real conditions. That’s why you should:

• Paper trade your system live before putting real money at risk.
• Compare the live trades with your backtest notes.
• Note differences caused by slippage, broker conditions, or unexpected volatility.

This step ensures your automation won’t break down when exposed to real-world trading.

Step 3: Keep a Trading Journal

Even with automation, keeping a trading journal gives you a deeper view of your system.

Benefits include:

• Accountability — you see exactly how your rules performed.
• Clarity — you can spot weaknesses in setups or parameters.
• Optimization — reviewing past trades highlights what to improve.

A journal can be as simple as a spreadsheet with trade details (entry, exit, result, notes) or as advanced as dedicated journaling software.

Final Thoughts

Before you automate, make sure your strategy has been tested, compared, and documented. Manual backtesting shows you how your rules behave in different market scenarios, live testing confirms they can handle real conditions, and journaling helps you refine for the long run.

Automation works best when built on a solid foundation. With clear data and insights, your algorithm won’t just run — it will run with confidence.

👉 Ready to take the next step and automate your tested strategy? Work with developers who understand trading at Milvetti.

‍

‍